Modern Oncology 2009,17(11):21 85-2 187
Clinical observation on cycle thermo chemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion for malignant peritoneal effusion
Jihua Yang , Jie Min , Weimin Li , Hong Wang , Rui Liu , Ningqiang Ma , Helong Zhang
Department of Oncology , Tang du Hospital,Fourth Military Medical University,Xi’an 710 038,China .
[Abstract] Objective : To evaluate the efficacy of cycle thermochemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion for malignant peritoneal effusion . Methods : Fifty six cases with malignant peritoneal effusion were randomly divided into two groups . After abdominal paracentesis and lavation , 29 cases were treated with cycle thermochemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion and 27 cases were treated with thermochemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion as control.Then the treatment effect and toxicities were assessed . Results : The response rate was 93.1%in treated group and 6 6.7%in the control group(P<0.025) . The hyperhidrosis is more frequently happened in therapy group(89.7%)than in control group(29.6%)(P<0.05) Conclusion : Cycle thermochemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion for malignant peritoneal effusion is an effective and well tolerated method for the malignant peritoneal effusion with slight side effect .
[Key words] Malignant pleural effusion ; thermotherapy ; perfusion ; cisplatine
Modern Oncology 2009,17(11):2185-2187
[CLC]R 730.53[Document ID code]A
The application of thermo chemotherapy of intraperitoneal perfusion for malignant peritoneal effusion with pharmacokinetic advantages and warm effecthad been wildly reported recently[2-4] . The traditional treatments of thermo chemotherapy using pre-warmed solution for perfusion and then heat the abdomen with microwave or radio frequency . However the constant hyperthermia temperature is hardly to reach , so the effect is hardly to be improved.The advent of cavity extracorporeal circulation perfusion machine may solve these problems , while the application of circulating perfusion thermochemotherapy in treatment of malignant peritoneal effusion had been rarely reported . Malignant ascites patients treated with circulating perfusion thermochemotherapy and simple hyperthermic perfusion chemotherapy were reviewed in this study to evaluate the therapeutic effect of circulating perfusion thermochemotherapy .
1Patients and Methods
56 patients diagnosed as malignant peritoneal effusion by pathology in our treatment center were collected from January 2007 , including 33 males,23 females,the median age of 55 years(54±16),the expected survival>3months.Encapsulated effusion were not formed,Including 17 cases of gastric carcinoma , 12 cases of liver cancer,colorectal cancer in 15 cases,12 cases of ovarian cancer . All the cases had B ultrasound examination results,by which ascites were classified :16 cases of grade I,21 cases of grade II and 19 cases of grade III . (Patients were in supine position when underwent B ultrasound examination,grade I : effusion exist between intestinal ; grade II : effusion exist between liver and kidney and paracolic sulci ; grade III : effusion exist before liver)
All of the cases met the inclusion criteria . And stratified randomization method was used . Firstly disease and ascites grade were stratified . Then simple randomized method was used in each layer to further divide the patients into treated group and control group . No heterogeneity of basic information was found between two groups(disease P>0.5;ascites P>0.75),Table1.
1.2.1Treatment plan All patients underwent bilateral abdominal paracentesis and lavage:abdominal paracentesis was performed in the left and right lower abdomen puncture point under the guided of B ultrasound . After that two needles were left and fixed , and connected with the disposable extracorporeal circulation catheter(one as input way and the other as output way)started the perfusion machine , and flooded abdominal cavity with preheating physiology saline at the temperature of 37～38℃。And the same time,output catheter was opened , and drained ascites and perfusion solution until the solution with lighter color of near to colorless . After drainage of fluid , further treatment was given according to treatment plan of each group .
Treated group①the centrifugal pump infusion hole of extracorporeal circulation perfusion machine(Harbin aerospace Technical Developing Company)was connected with inlet catheter , and centrifugal pump liquid hole is connected with the outlet catheter . So a closed loop of “ inlet catheter-Abdominal cavity.-outlet catheter-perfusion machine-inlet catheter ” was formed . The perfusion fluid(1500～3000ml saline+cisplatin 40～80mg , with concentration of 26.7%)was heated to 44.0～47.0℃before intraperitoneal injecting to the closed system .②Regulation of the perfusion machine to make the perfusion fluid circulating in the abdnominal cavity,and keep a constant temperature by real-time temperature measuring and heating when needed.The perfusion time was 60min.③Released amount of liquid after perfusion,then intraperitoneal injected of interleukin-II 3000000 u , 10mg dexamethasone , 200000U gentamicin.Pull out the puncture needles after routine disinfection.Pressure dressed the puncture point,ask patient to change position every fifteen minutes.Patients were in Observation wards until 30min after the treatment . ④The treatment was repeated every 3 days.4 times were considered to be 1 course of treatment .
Control group had the same treatment plan except perfusion fluid circulating.
1.2.2 Observation index①the change of perfusion fluid:the input volume , output volume and temperature ; ②Volume of ascites : abdominal ultrasound were performed before and 4 weeks after the fourth courses of treatment . ③Laboratory examination : routine blood test and serum alanine aminotransferase were tested at the the ninth day and 4 weeks after the first course of treatment . ④adverse reactions:record all kinds of adverse reactions during and after treatment .
1.2.3 Criterion of therapeutic evaluation
Therapeutic evaluation was classified according to WHO criteria : Complete remission(CR) , ascites disappeared completely , lasting more than 4 weeks ; Partial remission(PR) , ascites reduced at least 50% , and remission of symptoms continued for more than 4 weeks;No response(NR) , the change of ascites with less than 50%decreased or no more than 25%increased;Progressive disease(PD) , ascites increased or advanced . Complete remission and partial remission were defined as effective results.Adverse reactions were also concerned . It was classified according to the criteria of WHO.
1.3 Statistical analysis
Chi-square test and Fisher exact probability test were used.
2.1The change of perfusion fluid:the input volume,output volume and temperature
Treated group:The total volume was 1500ml～3000ml(mean of 2750ml)with the temperature of 46℃～47℃（mean of 46.5℃）.The output volume was 1000ml～3000ml(mean of 2000ml)with the temperature of 39.4℃～43.4℃（mean of 41.4℃）.Perfusion time was 60min.
Control group:The total volume was 1500ml～3000ml(mean of 2750ml)with the temperature of 46℃～47℃（mean of 46.5℃） . The output volume was 1000ml～3000ml(mean of 2000ml)with the temperature of 37.4～39.4℃（mean of 38.4℃）.Perfusion time was 60min .
2.2 Effect of treatment
The Effective rate of treatment in the treated group was CR 13.8%cases(4/29),PR 79.3%(23/29) , NR 6.9%(2/29) , with effective rate of 93.1%.In control group , the therapeutic effect was CR 3.7%(1/27),PR 63%(17/27) , NR 25.9%(7/27) , PD 7.4%(2/27)with the effective rate of the 66.7% . The effective rate of the treatment group was significantly higher than that in control group(X2=6.191,P<0.025) .Table2
2.3 adverse reactions
There were no significantly difference of adverse reactions between two groups except sweating(p<0.05) . The incidence rate of bone marrow suppression , gastrointestinal reaction , abdominal pain , abnormal liver function etc . And adverse reactions have no significantly difference . See table 3
Malignant ascites had high incidence in patients with malignant tumor . It affect the quality of life seriously . We applied cyclic heat perfusion chemotherapy for malignant peritoneal effusion , and achieved good effect . Circulation heat perfusion chemotherapy in tumor treatment has the following characteristics[5-6] . ①High temperature can kill the tumor cells directly.Malignant cells are 2 times more sensitive to high temperature than the normal cells . The ability of heat to killing tumor cells will increase 2 times with 1℃increased when the temperature is more than 42℃ . Or if prolong the time ,the ability still enhanced . Besides that , heat can accelerate the apoptosis of tumor cells,and activate the immune response . ②Synergistic effect of hyperthermia and chemotherapy . Heat has the effect of dilating of blood vessels and lymphatic vessels,increasing the cancer cell membrane fluidity,thus increase the concentration of chemotherapeutic agents in cancer cells . Heat can catalyze the reaction between drugs and tumor cells,and enhances the sensitivity of chemotherapy drugs,such as cisplatin . ③Intraperitoneal hyperthermic perfusion can wash away a number of cancer cells,and reduce tumor burden . Perfusion chemotherapy in abdominal cavity prolong the contact time of drug to tumor cells,so as to enhance the local concentration 10 times than the plasma concentration . From the above we know that,keeping the constant temperature of perfusion solution , complete contact of perfusion solution to organs and tissues were the key point to the ensure the effect of perfusion thermotherapy . So we let the perfusion solution circulating , and monitor the temperature in real-time mode in order to keep a constant temperature . Flow and heat carrier characteristics of water were also utilized to make the drug contact with organs completely . In this way , tumor cells can be killed effectively . That is to say ,“ circulating and temperature control ” were the key point .
According to the Y Ellinstudy , abdominal perfusion , temperature was equally to the average temperature of the inflow and outflow of perfusion . The proposed temperature in abdominal cavity was 43.9℃in this study , which ensure the safety and effective of the treatment . This is probably the most important reason for the test group has a good curative effect . While in the control group , traditional method without continued heating cannot make sure a constant temperature of 43℃in 1h . The traditional method without circulation of perfusion cannot wash away the tumor cells.So there was only 66.7%efficiency .
The experimental group used the method of cycle perfusion fluid , overcome the defects,to ensure the effective treatment temperature of thermo chemotherapy . The effective rate was 93.1%.Most of the patients in the treated group had the symptom of sweating in the circulation process ; it may be due high temperature induced by intraperitoneal perfusion therapy . For those patients , fluid infusion was given during treatment , and sweating symptoms disappear after the end of treatment . In the treatment process,the vital signs of the patients remain stable , no patients who could not tolerate the perfusion.Except for sweating,no grade III/IV hematologic adverse reactions were found . This study suggests that the circulating perfusion chemotherapy in treatment of malignant peritoneal effusion have the advantages of easy to operation,safety,good curative effect,fewer side effects .
Fujimura T,Yonemura Y,Fushida S,et al Continuous hyperthermic peritonea l perfusion for the treatment of peritoneal dissemination in gastric cancers and subsequent second-look operation[J].Cancer,1990,65(1):65-71.
Juan Bai.Current status and progress of intraperitoneal perfusion for the treatment of malignant ascites[J].West china medical journal.2007,22(2):428-429.
]Pantazis P,Han ZY,Wyche J.Schedule dependent efficiency of thermo-chemotherapy in vitro with etoposide and heating at 43degrees C[J].Anti cancer Res,1999,19(2A):995.
Zhongmin Chen.To observe the effect of hyperthermia and chemotherapy in HepA22 tumor bearing mice[J].Journal of Practical Oncology,2001,15(1):5–
Zicheng Yu,Suzhen Ye.Intraperitoneal administration of anti-tumor drug.Foreign pharmaceutical,synthetic medicine biochemical preparation.2002,23:3.
Q ian J,T ruebenb ach J,Graep le F,et a.l App lication of po lylactid ecoglycolid emicrospheres in the transarterial chemoembolizat ion in anan im al model of HCC[J].World J Gastroen terol 2003,9:948-949.
Renjun Zhai,Changqing He,Diwen Zeng,et al.Modern lung cancer diagnosis and treatment[M]Beijing:People's Medical Publishing House,1999:313-414
Port illa AG,Sugarbaker PH,Chang D.Second look surgely after cytoreduction and in trap eritoneal chemotherapy for peritoneal can c-inoma from colorectal cancer,analysis of prognostic features[J].Wodd J Surg,1999,23(1):23-29.
Yellin A,Simansky DA,Paley M,et al.Hyperthermic pleural perfusion with cisplatin:early clin ical exp erience[J].Can cer,2001,92(8):2197.
H amazoe R,M aeta M,K aibara N.In traperitoneal thermochemotherapy for prevention of p eritoneal recurren ce of gastric cancer.Final results of a randomized controlled study[J].Cancer,1994,73(8):2048-2052.